I don't understand why do you criticize these projects. If you don't like them, ok, everyone have own taste, but criticize...?
If I would like to have a logo made by (as you said) REAL graphic designer I would go to graphic agency and paid for it, but I think is nice to make something together.
For me more important is heart than level of designer skills. I'll be happy wearing t-shirt with logo made by our members no matter if will be chaotic or not, form '70 or not.
Some members of this forum spent part of their free time to make something for Inside-Volley and I really appreciate it!