Yes and? She's also the same height as Shinnabe but only 1/6 of her talent
But these are girls that were all under the strict guidance of coaches. Nakajima like you said is only a rookie there's still a good chance for her to bloom later on.
Hayashi was no monster rookie when she first started. Star quality is the most subjective factor in an athlete. I personally don't see any star quality in Hayashi but I'm not denying her massive talent as an allrounder that does not take away her potential to become an NT ace right? Like if I say Nonaka is the only rookie with star quality I'm sure many of you would question it.