was he wrong at that time though?
also, majority of players in his club are still Italians and the club is stationed in Italy. he only speaks English when needed and I'm sure fluency was not required so no, he isn't passing IELTS by any means. he isn't fluent. and it's not fair to demand language nuance from someone like him.
Theres no passing on the IELTS unless a uni sets a score for you to get in.